Where to Start: The Two Core Categories
The gay man’s guide to sex toys starts with the most useful framing: the two most common entry points for gay men into sex toys are anal play and solo stimulation. Everything else builds from or runs alongside these two categories. Starting with one and exploring from there is more effective than trying to cover every category at once.
Anal Play: Plugs, Dildos, and Anatomy
Anal play is probably the most common reason gay men start exploring sex toys. The category divides into butt plugs (designed for wear, for the sensation of fullness and the stretch of the sphincter), dildos (designed for active stimulation, prostate targeting, and depth), and vibrating toys that add motor-driven stimulation to either category.
For a first toy: a silicone butt plug in the smaller range is the standard recommendation. It is body-safe, introduces the sensation of anal penetration in a controlled way, and is easy to use solo. From there, the natural progression is a curved dildo for prostate stimulation, and eventually larger sizes as comfort and capacity develop.
The prostate is located approximately 5-7cm inside the rectum on the anterior (front) wall. Direct prostate stimulation produces a sensation that is different from any surface stimulation and is a significant part of why anal toys are a distinct experience rather than simply a substitute for something else.
Cock Rings: How and Why
A cock ring is the second most common entry-level toy for men. It applies constriction at the base of the shaft, slowing the outflow of blood from the erectile tissue during arousal. The result is a fuller, firmer erection that sustains longer than without restriction. Many men also report a more intense orgasm at the end of a session with a ring on.
Silicone cock rings are the right starting point. The Tyre Cock Ring 2pk is one of the most affordable options and works for most men. Vibrating rings add stimulation on top of the constriction. Metal rings provide more firmness and weight but require accurate sizing.
Masturbators and Strokers
Masturbators are sleeves or cup-style toys that add texture, pressure, and sometimes suction or vibration to manual stimulation. The quality difference between a basic budget sleeve and a well-designed masturbator is genuine. A masturbator with thoughtful internal texture provides stimulation that is not possible with the hand alone.
For an extended session approach, automatic masturbators provide hands-free stimulation. For edging practice, a manual sleeve with low-resistance texture allows more control over stimulation pace.
Ball Stretchers and Pump Toys
Ball stretchers apply sustained pull to the scrotum. The sensation is different from anything else in the category, a constant outward tension that heightens scrotal awareness throughout a session. Penis pumps apply vacuum to the shaft, causing temporary engorgement. Both categories are about physical sensation and, for consistent users, gradual physical conditioning over time.
Silicone ball stretchers are the correct starting point. Air pumps are accessible and effective for penis pumping. Water pumps like the HydroMax 7 are a step up.
Kink Gear: Entry Points
Kink gear covers a wide range. For gay men new to kink, the most accessible entry points are cock rings worn as part of a kink session, light restraints like velcro wrist cuffs, and a chest harness for aesthetic and sensory play during sex. These three categories are low commitment, relatively affordable, and give a genuine read on which direction your kink interests point.
Pup play gear, chastity devices, electro play, impact implements, and sounding are all further along the specificity spectrum. Each has its own learning curve and community knowledge base.
Sex Dolls and Realistic Toys
Realistic toys, from simple strokers with realistic orifice textures through to full torso sex dolls, occupy a category that is about immersion and physical realism in solo play. The appeal is the qualitatively different experience of a realistic surface compared to a neutral sleeve.
At the accessible end: realistic strokers and smaller orifice toys. At the committed end: torso dolls like the Bro’s Bum or the Bendy Babe XL. Weight is the practical consideration. Under 5kg remains manageable for storage and cleaning. Over that, logistics become a real factor.
Materials: What You Need to Know
Silicone is body-safe, non-porous, and sterilisable. It is the gold standard for anal toys in particular. TPE is softer, often cheaper, used for masturbators and sex dolls, but porous and cannot be fully sterilised. Metal and glass are non-porous and fully sterilisable. Each material has appropriate use cases. See the sex toy materials guide for the full breakdown.
Building a Collection Over Time
The most common pattern is a modest start with one or two toys, development of clear preferences from using those, and gradual expansion into areas that have generated genuine curiosity. There is no correct collection. There is only what works for you.
Every major category covered in this guide has its own dedicated post on the Manatomy blog. Whatever area appeals, there is a specific how-to guide waiting.
Related guides: Sex Toy Materials Guide: Silicone, TPE, Metal, Glass and More • How to Use Your First Butt Plug: A Relaxed Guide for Men
Shop the range: anal play